For the Birds

I was happy to see tweets about my very positive review of the film, Ordinary Extraordinary Junco.  And that got me to thinking about some advice from my advisor back when I was in graduate school.

I did my Ph.D. in Zoology at the University of North Carolina under the supervision of the late, great Nelson G. Hairston, Sr.  (By the way, Nelson Jr. is also a superb evolutionary ecologist, on the faculty at Cornell.)

Nelson Sr. told his students that they could work on anything except birds.  Why?  Because too many people love them (as did he) and, more importantly, because birds were just too difficult to study – especially if one intended to pursue an experimental approach, which for Nelson was the best kind of biology, even in the field.  Working with Nelson, you could study salamanders, protozoa, insects (like my carabid beetles) … any animals except birds.

I may not have all the details right after all these years, but I recall Nelson telling about an ecologist who was trying to manipulate the density of a bird population (this was back in the day when there were still intense debates about the importance of density dependence in ecological dynamics) by shooting birds, only to have other birds from neighboring areas immediately move back onto the study plot, thereby defeating the intended manipulation.

So it’s interesting that now, 30+ years later, juncos and Darwin’s finches are the stars of two of the greatest long-term eco-evolutionary studies.

There are at least two lessons here.  First, young scientists should not always accept what their advisors say.  Listen carefully and discuss, but make your own decisions.  Second, it’s amazing what extraordinary people like Ellen Ketterson and Peter & Rosemary Grant can accomplish when they put their minds, energy, and professional lives into understanding the evolving world in which we live.


Filed under Science

6 responses to “For the Birds

  1. A great read, thank you.

    I think your advice even extends way beyond science. Music is my field, and I certainly benefited from the advice and wisdom of many great musicians in my formative years (and to this day)..

    But while a learned elder always deserves to be heard and their advice considered, ultimately we must all choose our own path.

    • Thanks, Manning. I’m very glad you enjoyed and could relate to this post, despite our different fields of endeavor.

      I hope you’ll enjoy my next post, too. It’s a personal story about the intersection of science and humor that happened just today …

  2. I’ve also heard that story about the ecologist trying to do a density manipulation by shooting birds, only to find he was actually doing an experiment on dispersal. But I can’t recall who the ecologist was, and I have no idea of the original source. Any ideas?

    p.s. Welcome to the blogosphere, love the blog.

  3. Pingback: Links 8/27/13 | Mike the Mad Biologist

  4. Pingback: Luria and Delbrück, 1943, Genetics | Telliamed Revisited